Legal & Compliance

Short-term rentals worldwide: the EU Court, Budapest, Puglia, Ireland and Tokyo

The EU Court says when a city may require authorisation, Budapest’s moratorium is due to expire, and Puglia, Ireland and Tokyo change the rules. As of 26 October 2026.

A globe and lavender in a glass vase on a window sill, with the rooftops of a European city and an arched bridge over a river at dusk.
Illustrative AI-generated image

Beyond Romania, Greece and Spain, the past few weeks have brought a ruling from the Court of Justice of the EU on authorising short-term rentals, a debate in Budapest about what follows the moratorium, and new rules in Puglia, Ireland and Tokyo. Many of the decisions are taken at the level of the city, district or building, while EU law sets the conditions. As of 26 October 2026, some of these rules have been adopted, while others depend on steps that have not yet happened.

What is a ruling, what is law and what is only a bill

Not all news carries the same weight. A ruling of the EU Court interprets European law, but the national court decides the actual case. A law adopted by a regional council needs local regulations before it produces concrete limits, and a bill can still change in parliament.

TopicStatusKey dateWhat to do
CJEU ruling in Case C-813/24Delivered; the case returns to the Brussels Court of Appeal22 October 2026Note the conditions for any local authorisation
Budapest moratoriumIn force; expires unless extended31 December 2026Check the district and building rules
Vote in Budapest’s District IOnline consultation; a regulatory framework is to follow30 September 2026Do not treat the result as a rule in force
Puglia lawAdopted by the regional council; limits come through municipal regulations20 October 2026Follow the municipality’s regulation
Irish registerBill before parliament; opening announced by the government1 December 2026Prepare your planning documents
Bunkyo restrictions (Tokyo)Amendment adopted by the ward assemblyJanuary 2027Check the area before any investment

The EU Court: prior authorisation is allowed, with conditions

The case began with Smartflats, a Brussels company that let homes on a short-term basis. In 2021, the Brussels-Capital Region rejected its prior declaration as incomplete, and in 2022 it ordered the company to stop operating because it had neither a fire safety certificate nor a registration number. Brussels rules also require a certificate of town planning compliance, and when the permitted use of a building changes from “dwelling” to “hotel establishment”, planning permission is needed. The Brussels Court of Appeal asked the EU Court whether these requirements comply with the Services Directive.

On 22 October 2026, the Court answered in five points:

  • Town planning falls under the directive. Town planning rules on the use of buildings fall under the Services Directive when they form part of the authorisation scheme for tourist accommodation.
  • Prior authorisation can be justified. Protecting tourists and the urban environment, including housing, can justify authorisation if the scheme is necessary, given its geographical scope and its impact on residential needs, and if a less restrictive measure would not be enough, for example because a later inspection would come too late.
  • The conditions must be clear. The certificate of town planning compliance may be required if it meets the directive’s criteria and can be obtained under transparent and accessible conditions. The municipality’s discretion in classifying the property does not breach the directive, because it is limited by those criteria and has safeguards against arbitrary use.
  • The procedure has safeguards. Applications must be decided within a reasonable time limit, set and published in advance, refusals must give reasons, and there must be a right of appeal.
  • Only the faulty condition falls. If the scheme is justified but one condition breaches the directive, only that condition is set aside, provided it can be separated from the rest of the scheme.

The case now returns to the Brussels Court of Appeal, which will apply these criteria. CCIA Europe, an association of technology companies, has asked the European Parliament and the Council to reject what it describes as the Commission’s proposal to take short-term rental restrictions out of the Services Directive, as part of the Affordable Housing Act.

The ruling does not directly change the rules in Romania, Greece or Spain. It does, however, show the conditions that, according to the Court, an authorisation for tourist accommodation covered by the Services Directive must meet: necessity, proportionality, clear criteria, published time limits, reasons and a right of appeal.

Budapest: the moratorium ends, the districts make their own rules

Since 1 January 2025, Hungary’s trade law has banned the registration of new private accommodation in Budapest until 31 December 2026. Homes already registered have continued to operate, but even a change of operator could no longer be registered. Also from 2025, the annual flat-rate tax per room for private accommodation rose from HUF 38,400 to HUF 150,000 in places with more than 2 million guest nights, which in practice means Budapest. According to Jogihírek, if lawmakers do not act, new registrations will be possible again from 1 January 2027. The Hungarian Apartment Letting Association (MAKE) asked on 14 September for the moratorium to be extended by one year. As of 26 October 2026, we found no public decision to extend it.

The districts are using their own tools. Terézváros (District VI) cut to zero, from 1 January 2026, the number of days a year a home can be let to tourists, a rule upheld by Hungary’s Supreme Court (Kúria). Erzsébetváros (District VII) chose zero days as the general rule and 365 days where the building’s owners have agreed. Józsefváros (District VIII) adopted a framework on 25 June with caps: 3.5% of the district’s homes, 5% in Palotanegyed and Corvin, 1–2% in the outer quarters and 20% of the floor area of each building, plus the consent of the owners’ general assembly for any new unit. The detailed regulations were announced for the autumn; as of 26 October 2026, we found no official announcement of their adoption.

In District I (Budavár, the Castle District), 58.5% of participants in a consultative online vote backed a full ban on short-term rentals. About 4,500 of 21,450 eligible residents voted, or 21%. The district will draw up a regulatory framework, also taking an impact assessment into account. In District XIII, the public consultation on the draft regulation closed on 2 October.

The end of the moratorium is not a free pass. Even if the national moratorium is not extended, district and building rules can limit or block a new unit. For an investment in Budapest, the exact address matters.

Puglia: tourist municipalities may set zones and limits

On 20 October, Puglia’s regional council adopted the law on tourist lets, with 29 votes in favour, according to ANSA. Municipalities with the highest tourist density, as classified by the national statistics institute ISTAT, and all provincial capitals may use their own regulations to define zones with criteria and limits for tourist lets, whether or not they are run as a business. Among other things, municipalities must consider the ratio between beds in tourist lets and the resident population, the capacity of accommodation facilities and the impact on affordable housing. They may also set a ratio between floor area and the number of guests, as well as quality standards.

The law excludes people who let their main residence, a choice inspired by the proposed EU Affordable Housing Act. According to ARET Pugliapromozione data from September 2026, 87.13% of tourist lets in the region and 85.38% of beds are not run as a business. Municipalities must provide transitional rules for homes already let legally. The opposition criticised the law as an attack on private property. The actual limits will only appear in municipal regulations.

Ireland: a national register and fines for platforms

On 6 October, the Irish government published the Short Term Letting and Tourism Bill, which implements Regulation (EU) 2024/1028. Fáilte Ireland, the national tourism development authority, becomes the competent authority and will keep a national register for stays of up to 21 nights.

  • A number on every listing. Hosts must obtain a registration number and display it on all listings.
  • Duties for platforms. Platforms must display the numbers, carry out random checks, share data and remove non-compliant listings. In serious cases, fines can reach 2% of annual worldwide turnover.
  • Planning. To register, hosts must confirm that they comply with planning rules. In places with fewer than 20,000 inhabitants, hosts have two years to regularise.
  • Timeline. The government says the register opens on 1 December, and in May it said hosts must register by 31 December 2026.

As of 26 October 2026, the Fáilte Ireland page said that registration was not yet open, that it would start once the law was passed and that fees would be announced. The bill must go through the Irish parliament (the Oireachtas).

Tokyo: Bunkyo extends its restrictions to the whole ward

On 7 October, the assembly of Tokyo’s Bunkyo ward adopted an amendment to the local ordinance on minpaku, private homes let to tourists. From January 2027, the restrictions apply across the entire ward. According to News On Japan, Bunkyo already banned minpaku operation on weekdays around schools and in residential-only zones, and the amendment adds commercial districts, including those around Tokyo Dome.

One of the reasons: the neighbouring wards of Shinjuku, Toshima and Taito have already tightened their rules, and Bunkyo wants to stop operators from relocating to its territory. Budapest’s District I cites a similar risk: a wave of new registrations once the moratorium expires.

What this news means for Romania, Greece and Spain

Most of these rules move the decision closer to the address: city, district, building. In the EU, the Smartflats ruling shows the limits: authorisation must be necessary and proportionate and must follow a fair procedure. The negotiations on the Affordable Housing Act will decide how much room cities get.

For the countries where you can analyse listings with KeyBid Genius, see our 26 October articles on Romania, Greece and Spain. For the US, Canada and Australia, see our analysis of 21 October.

Rumours and speculation: what can be checked as of 26 October

Many interpretations of these changes are circulating. Here are the questions that matter for owners and investors, and what the published documents show.

  • “Has the EU Court banned cities from restricting short-term rentals?” No. The Court said that prior authorisation can be justified if it is necessary and proportionate and follows a fair procedure. Whether the Brussels scheme meets these conditions is for the Belgian court to decide.
  • “Will the Budapest moratorium be extended?” MAKE has asked for a one-year extension. As of 26 October 2026, we found no public decision to that effect, and several districts are preparing their own rules.
  • “Is Puglia banning tourist lets?” No. The law only allows municipalities with high tourist density and provincial capitals to set zones and limits, and main residences are excluded.
  • “Will the Irish register definitely open on 1 December?” The government has announced that date. Fáilte Ireland says, however, that registration starts once the law is passed, which as of 26 October 2026 had not happened, according to the agency’s page.
  • “Will the Affordable Housing Act take short-term rentals out of the Services Directive?” According to CCIA Europe, that is what the Commission’s proposal provides, and the association wants it rejected. The final text depends on negotiations in the European Parliament and the Council.

What you can do now

  1. Check the rule at address level. In Budapest, Puglia or Tokyo, the district, the municipality and the building matter more than national law. A rule that applies in one district tells you nothing about the next one.
  2. Keep evidence of the procedure. If you apply for an authorisation, keep the filing dates, replies and refusals. According to the EU Court, an authorisation procedure needs published time limits, reasons and a right of appeal.
  3. Read the building rules. In Budapest’s Districts VII and VIII, the consent of the building’s owners becomes a condition. Check the building’s rules before you buy.
  4. Work out the return with real figures. Before a purchase, set the estimated income against the costs. For a home in Romania, Greece or Spain, see our KeyBid Genius guide.
  5. Follow the EU negotiations. The Affordable Housing Act will set how much room cities have to restrict short-term rentals. The final text may differ from the proposal.

A financial estimate does not replace a legal check. KeyBid Genius estimates the return, but it does not check authorisations, district rules or building rules. These need to be clarified separately, before you buy.

Frequently asked questions

Does the EU Court ruling also apply in Romania, Greece or Spain?

The Court’s interpretation of the Services Directive matters in every EU country, but the ruling concerns the Brussels scheme. Whether a national or local rule meets the Court’s conditions is decided case by case, by the authorities and the courts.

Can new homes be registered for tourist accommodation in Budapest from 2027?

Under the law in force on 26 October 2026, the moratorium expires on 31 December 2026. Even so, district rules can limit or ban new units, as already happens in District VI.

Does the Irish register also cover rooms in the host’s own home?

Yes. According to Fáilte Ireland, any host offering paid accommodation for up to 21 nights must register each unit, including rooms in their own home. Hotels, hostels and campsites are not covered by this register.

What does the Puglia law mean for people who let their main residence?

The limits set by municipalities do not apply to people who let their main residence. For other homes, the actual limits will appear in municipal regulations.

Tags: